Kelly as seen in HIDE AND SEEK
How it Appeared
He appeared when Anthony was alone eating: Ian picked up the bread from Anthony's plate and put it with him and Ian drew a face for company.
- As mentioned on the BTS video, when Ian ate Kelly he was actually eating a different slice of bread that didn't have any marker on it.
- Kelly is most likely a parody of Wilson the Volleyball from the movie Castaway.
- Kelly is male because he tells Ian that he is a man after Ian ate him.