Brief Synopsis: Anthony tries to propose to his girlfriend, but one thing leads to another when he is accused of stealing someone's ice cream.
Anthony (wearing a tuxedo) calls his girlfriend and tells her to go to the place where they first met. Ian is watching TV, and Anthony walks in. Seeing that he has a tuxedo on, Ian asks where he's going before calling him "Mr. Fancy Tux McGayerson." Anthony tells him that he's going to propose to his girlfriend Maggie. Ian asks, "Maggie as in the girl you met a month ago?" Anthony dismisses his comment by saying, "We're in love, ok? Don't be jealous." Ian wishes him good luck getting rejected.
Anthony is waiting a a comic book store, and a cowboy (Ian) tells Anthony to hold his ice cream. Anthony is confused, but doesn't have time to ask questions, as the cowboy leaves the store with no explanation. The ice cream starts to melt in his hands, and Anthony tries to keep his tux clean by licking the melted ice cream. The ice cream falls off the cone and lands on the floor.
The cowboy comes in and sees that the ice cream is gone, and accuses Anthony of eating it. Anthony tries to tell him what happened, but the cowboy doesn't believe him. A hobo in the store calls Anthony "a disgrace to America," and then a police man tells Anthony that he owes the cowboy an ice cream, unless Anthony wants the police man to take him downtown. He adds that it wasn't a sexual reference. A priest then comes in and tells Anthony to admit to his sins. Anthony still tries to explain to them that he didn't eat the ice cream, but the priest says to the cowboy, "Someone's going to hell."
Anthony's grandma comes in and says that she's very disappointed in him. Then, the Tux shop owner comes in and takes Anthony's tuxedo, saying that they don't rent out their tuxedos to jerks. Anthony's grandma says that when she dies, she's leaving everything to his sister, including her dog, Kevin Bacon. Anthony is outraged that nobody believes him, and exclaims, "Where are you guys even coming from?!" The cowboy says that Anthony owes him $0.50, and another hobo says that he found a briefcase with a million dollars in it. He was going to share it, but refuses since Anthony's an "ice cream stealing bastard." Then he calls him a vile creature.
Maggie comes in and, at first, Anthony is relieved. But Maggie slaps Anthony and yells at him for eating the cowboy's ice cream. Anthony says it's just a big misunderstanding, but Maggie doesn't believe it and dumps him. Anthony gives up and gives the cowboy $0.50, but the cowboy says that he now owes him a dollar, since he wants to take Maggie out for ice cream. Anthony gives up and throws his wallet on the ground and gives the ring to the cowboy.
The cowboy takes Maggie out and everyone starts to leave, but not before the priest whispers to Anthony, "You're still going to hell." The green sweatered hobo takes Anthony's wallet. The hobo with the breifcase confesses that he doesn't have money in the briefcase. He opens it up to reveal that it's just his rock collection. As Anthony leaves, the police officer starts to explain that his "downtown" remark was not a sexual reference, unless Anthony's interested.
Back at home, Ian asks Anthony if he "popped the question." Anthony says yes, and the police officer pops up behind him, commentig on how beautiful the ring is.
The cowboy takes Maggie out and everyone starts to leave, but not before the priest whispers to Anthony, "You're still going to hell." However, a guy comes in and tells Anthony that he's been the victim of a prank for a hidden camera show, I'm An Idiot. Anthony asks if everything is fake, including the cowboy taking Maggie out. During this, the cowboy proposes to Maggie, in which she says yes. The cowboy exclaims that love at first sight really does exist, and then they run away together. The guy says that that part's real before asking Anthony to sign a talent release. An angry Anthony signs the release under the name "Justin Bieber", but signed it as "Justin Beiber". The guy believes that Anthony is really Justin Bieber, and asks him to autograph his nipple.
- Anthony gave the ring to the cowboy, but at home, the police officer has the ring as if Anthony never gave it away.
- In the alternate ending, Justin Bieber's name is spelled, "Justin Beiber".
- The priest should know that Anthony is telling the truth, unless he is a fake priest or he simply hates Anthony.
- In reality, anyone is allowed to rent tuxedos, as long as they are returned by the due date.
Shut Up! Opening
- "*Wedding music* SHUT UP!"
PREVIEW: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Theme / Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Theme / Battleship / Transformers Theme / Smosh Short 1: Dolls / The California Stereotype Experiment / Boxman / Smosh Short 2: Stranded / The Best Car EVER / Food Battle 2006 / That Damn Neighbor / Frankie Rogers is James Bond / How Not to Make a First Impression / How Not to Act on a First Date / Feet For Hands / Boxman's Christmas / New Year's Eve PSA
Three Wishes / Axe Murderer / Easy Step / Sparky Goes to a Club / Spiderman, Spiderman / License Test / April First / Anthony Gets a Haircut / Handshake / Hardcore Max / Food Battle 2007 / Transformers Rap / Three Guys in a Hotel / Quest for the Scooter / The Assassins / Replacement Needed / Reunited? / Male Model / The Haunting / Toy Airplane / Ian's Birthday / Santa is Real!
Cat Soup / Boxman's Girlfriend / Left Handed / There Will Be Pokemon / Smosh Sued for $20 Million (April Fools) / Beef 'n Go / Batman's Cool Internet Video / Teleporting Fat Guy / Food Battle 2008 / Going to the Mountains / Life as Ghosts / Boxman for President / Sex Ed Rocks / Smosh Snatchers / A Merry Gangsta Christmas
Breaking the Habit / Hardcore Max 2 / Ian's First Girlfriend / That Damn Prison Break / Unitarded / LeVar Burton Buys Smosh (April Fools) / Anthony's Death / Anthony's Resurrection / Anthony is Mexican / Grammar Police / I Heart Burgers / A Hairy Situation w/ Billy Mays / A Very Hairy Situation w/ Billy Mays / Washington's First Video Blog / Food Battle 2009 / The Ultimate Shoedown / Bigfoot is Gay / If Movies Were Real / Four Years Foreplay / Twilight: New Moon Deleted Scenes / Mighty Smoshin POWER RANGERS / Kid Craps Himself in Drift Car! / Pizza Zombies! / X-Mas: PORN on Santa's Computer / X-Mas: Osama's First Christmas / X-Mas: Santa Gets Down / Best of Smosh 2009
Charlie the Drunk Guinea Pig / Ian Gets Lucky / Anthony Gets Engaged / HELP! WE'RE FAT! / EDITOR! / CRAZY FATASS! (True Story 1) / Ian Is Pregnant / If Video Games Were Real / Anthony Poses for Playgirl!?! / Smeagol Loves the Precious / Boxman 2.0 / I Love Lou Ferrigno! / Leave It To Bieber / Charlie the Drunk Guinea Pig 2 / 5 Ways to Get a Girl / Lizard Rabies / Super Powers! / My Mom's AMAZING Video! / How Lady Gaga Got Famous / The Famous Cheese Guy / WTF! I'm Old! / Inappropriate Sonic / Arm Wrestling TO THE DEATH / KILLER TEDDY BEAR! / If Cartoons Were Real / Food Battle 2010 / FIRETRUCK! / 2 GUYS 1 BATHROOM / SELLING OUT!? / ★ MY FANNY PACK! ★ / PLAYING WITH GUNS! / THE FUTURE SUCKS! / That Damn Punishment / If Scary Movies Were Real / HALO RUINED MY LIFE! (True Story 2) / EPIC TEENY BATTLE! / HARRY POTTER DELETED SCENES! / Pokemon Theme Song REVENGE / VADER AND ME! / Cute Furry Kittens / TRON: Legacy *LEAKED FOOTAGE* / MY NEW HOT GIRLFRIEND / Best of 2010 Remix
HOW TO HIDE A B0NER IN PUBLIC! / Paranormal Easy Bake Oven! / *NEW* Smosh Reality TV Show! / I'M NAKED! / HOT ROBOT SLAVE / JUSTIN BIEBER HITS PUBERTY (Never Say Never 2) / If Kids Shows Were Real / AMAZING NEW DRINK! / Charlie the Drunk Guinea Pig 3 / Charlie the Drunk Guinea Pig 3.5 / WORST TWIST ENDINGS EVER! / I KILLED THE TOOTH FAIRY! / MEETING MY IDENTICAL TWIN! / 3D is AWESOME! / I'M A PIRATE (True Story 3) / POKEMON IN REAL LIFE! / OUR VIDEO IDEAS STOLEN! / Runbrella (No. 1 MOTHER'S DAY GIFT!) / If Superheroes Were Real / DRIVING ME CRAZY!!! / REJECTED VIDEOS! / HOW TO DUMP YOUR GIRLFRIEND! / MY MAGICAL TAPEWORM! / POKEMON IN REAL LIFE 2! / MY BATHROOM SECRET / If The Internet Was Real / I'M NOT RACIST!!! / The Harry Potter Pill / MY GRANDPA'S DIRTY SECRET / If Movies Were Real 2 / First Person Shooters Suck! / Best Toy Ever! / Makeup For Men / Star Fox TV Show! / HOW TO COVER UP A MURDER / Food Battle 2011 / The Internet For Dummies / THE DITTO - Movie Trailer / XTREME SLEEPOVER! / POKEMON IN REAL LIFE 3! / THE NEW GHOSTBUSTERS / TEENS IN THE WILD! / REAL VOODOO DOLL! / The Legend of Zelda Rap / The Pokemon Master! / Motion Gaming Sucks! / I'M POSSESSED! / Meat in Your Mouth / If Holidays Were Real / Best of 2011 Remix!
SIRI TRIED TO KILL ME! / HOW TO BE A COP! / REAL DEATH NOTE! / MIME FAIL! / Parents Suck! / I WAS BRAINWASHED! / REJECTED TWILIGHT ZONE EPISODES! / HITCHHIKING DISASTER! / Attention: Facebook Users / POKEMON IN REAL LIFE 4! / I LOST MY HAIR! / HOMELESS MILLIONAIRE! / N1PPLES ON YOUTUBE! / Smosh On The News! / GUYS' GUIDE TO HUGGING GUYS / If Video Games Were Real 2 / STUCK IN A TOILET! / MANSPIDER! / Magic Keyboard! / 7YR OLD DOES TWILIGHT! / I SUCK AT DRAWING SOMETHING! / HOW TO CHEAT ON YOUR GIRLFRIEND! / SMOSH FOUND DEAD / REJECTED MARIO GAMES / 15 HOUR ENERGY! / My Mail Order Bride! / PEN15 CLUB / MY NEW EMO HAIR! / 5,000,000 SUBSCRIBERS! / OISHI WILL KICK YOUR ASS! / LIFE HACKING! / AWESOME NEW ROBOT! / Stupid Movie Sequels / WORST ID PHOTO EVER! / Taken 3 - TRAILER / IPhone 5 REVEALED / FOOD BATTLE 2012 ANNOUNCEMENT! / THAT'S HOT! / DRINK YOUR P!SS / BIGGEST ZIT EVER! / PHOTOSHOP PLASTIC SURGERY / BADASS NEW POWER RANGERS / GAMER GETS TROLL'D! / Food Battle 2012 / Teleporting Fat Guy is BACK! / Ultimate Assassin's Creed 3 Song / Addicted to Honey Boo Boo Child / Wii U Sports is Awesome! / My Pet Pikachu / DUBSTEP COMMERCIALS SUCK! / GIRLFRIENDS IN THE WILD / If TV Shows Were Real / A SMOSHY CHRISTMAS! (Part 1) / A SMOSHY CHRISTMAS! (Part 2) / Best of 2012 REMIX
Disney Star Wars / My Bobblehead is Evil! / Holy Crap! 2 Billion Views! / We're in Super Mario! / That Damn Movie! / Driver's Ed Crap Rap! / Most Violent Game Ever!? / My Stupid Dying Grandpa! / Sexting Gone Wrong! / Life Better-ers! / Banned Airplane Safety Video / Zelda in Real Life! / Worst Online Date Ever / Gas Buster! / If Movies Were Real 3 / Google Glass Sucks! / Sleeping Pill Disaster / Worst Proposals Ever / Amazing New Workout / Good Vs Surprisingly Good / Dixon Cider / We're Stuck Together!!! / What Guys Are Really Thinking / Stop Copying Me! / My Friend's Hot Sister / Japanese Titanic / We Need Friends / Magic Wipes / I Broke My Foot! / The Rarest Pokemon Card! / We Rule High School / I Have Kirby Powers! / Retarded Cats: The Movie / I Have a Secret Son / How to Survive a Burglary / So Many Hickeys! / Our Generation is F*cked: The Movie / Scribblenauts in Real Life / My Twerking Addiction / New Pokemon Crossovers! / Stop Miley / Assassin's Creed 4 Rock Anthem / 22 Crazy Vines (That Don't Exist) / Food Battle 2013 / Loki Interview Prank / We Found a Dead Guy! / Longest Staring Contest Ever / My Mutant Rash! / Smosh Vs Zombies / The End of Christmas (Part 1) / The End of Christmas (Part 2) / Best of 2013 Remix
Horny Cellmate / Molester Moon / Guy's Guide to Being Manly / Movies Vs Reality / Pimps of Prom / Jurassic Pokemon / Hide and Seek / Taylor Swift Dumped Me / Flappy Bird Ruined My Life / Creepy Weird Nudist / Pokemon in Real Life 5! / A Real Ouija Board? / Emma Watson Surprise Prank / If Video Games Were Real 3 / How to Be a YouTube Commenter / The Adventure Time Adventure / Movie Reboots Suck / Real Mario Lava Floor! / The Real Party Song / 19 More Crazy Vines (That Don't Exist) / Real Watch Dogs Hacks! / We're Stuck in Slow Motion / Addicted to Selfies / If Apps Were Real / Name Rap or Die / I Can Hear Your Thoughts / Anime Voice Swap / My Bathroom Disaster / My Morning Routine / The Rock Interview Prank / Real Minecraft Vacation / Disney's Star Wars Blind Date / If Bieber Wrote His Songs / If TV Shows Were Real 2 / Autocorrect Fail / iPhone 6 Revealed / Movies on Drugs / Conjoined Challenge / F**k Spoilers! / Your Dumb. I'm Dumber / This Video is Offensive / Backwards Challenge / Guns Suck / The New Slenderman / 6 Ways to Get a Girl / 9 Most Horrible Bosses / Ultimate Fan Suprise Prank / Food Battle 2014 / Top 10 Video Game Dances / Magic iPod / Just Like Link / Christmas Apocalypse (Part 1) / Christmas Apocalypse (Part 2)